So which of the girls do you think will be voted out? I think it will be Melissa & Kinnick.

definitely kinnik.. she was way off key last night
melissa is a good possibility even though i think she did a pretty good job.. she may get voted off b/c she doesn't have the best 'look'

i liked lisa, but my friends didn't know the song she sang and weren't impressed
i didn't like ayla's song, but i hope she stays

Yeah I hope Lisa & Ayla stay. I didn't like Ayla's sone either. As for the guys I think it may be Kevin & Ace that go. But the guys really did a good job so it will be close I think.

i was pleasantly surprised it was gideon that went instead of kevin
but i was sad to see ayla go

I've got it taped so I haven't see who went yet. I'm going to watch it tonight.

Ace isn't going anywhere any time soon. He's too pretty.

Yeah I hated to see Ayla go. I figured it would be Kinnick-Yeah! and Melissa. The guys I couldn't tell but I was surprised it was Will but not too surprised Gideon went.

My prediction this week is Melissa!

quote:

Originally posted by XenaFairy3:
Ace isn't going anywhere any time soon. He's too pretty.

Yeah he could stand up there pick his nose and not utter a note and people would vote for him.

Looks like my prediction was right! WooHoo!

I thought the best performances came from Taylor and Chris....I of course enjoyed Katherine as well. I got the McPhever.

Yeah Taylor & Chris did very well. The boys have talent. And Katherine is good every week.

So who will go tonight? I think it could either be Ace, Bucky or Kevin.

Well little Kevin is out!

I know someone at work that will be very happy.

I'm not too disappointed either!

i thought it would be bucky or lisa, but i'm okay with it being kevin

I think Bucky's next.

I think you're right. He's been in the bottom 3 too many times!

I think it will be him tonight or Lisa to go.

they were all disappointing last night

Yeah they were. I was surprised Bucky wasn't in the bottom 3 and that Katherine was. But I'm not surprised Lisa is the one that went.

Yeah, I have a min to be online!!!

Katherine looked caught off guard. I do think she is one of the best singers to be on Idol, but her song choices are probably hurting her chances. I like her style and her taste, I just don't think she's into POP. She seems like a kid who might have grown up with parents that listened to anything and everything, not just what was getting radio play.

Gotta love Chris, I knew he was a fan of LIVE from day one. Didn't hurt that he's done a couple of their songs, but I knew 8><8 mmhm

Mandisa is amazing. I would love to see a big girl with a big voice take this thing all the way.

I'll buy Taylor's CD - regardless, he's in a different league.

Elliot - not doin' too much for me lately.

Bucky - well... Oh Hell, I admit it, don't like the country thing, but he's cute as a can be.

Ace - damn near makes Clay look butch.

Kelly - my whole family lives 100 miles east of nowhere Appalachia and they aren't that 'country'.

Paris and Lisa - I think are both too young, talented, but young.

Pretty good synopsis! It's fun to predict who will go each week. And I do think Bucky and Ace's days are numbered. They've been in the bottom 3 too many times.

Even my Katharine was bad...I'm blaming it on the arrangement.